Little, big

July 26, 2009

little big 480

One of these things ought to be familiar, but the other one may not be (they are shown to scale here). The first commenter to correctly identify them both wins 100 SV-POW!bucks (TM), which aren’t worth diddly in the real world* but can be exchanged for worship, admiration, and bragging rights on teh intert00bz.

The contest will run until someone gets the right answer or the week is out. All will be revealed next week. Mike and Darren are forbidden to compete, not because it would be unfair but because I don’t like them very much.

This isn’t an impossible task, by the way. The info is out there. The only question is whether you are lonely geeky awesome enough to solve the mystery.

* That’s just a guess. It’s possible that at SVP you might find someone who would you buy you a beer in exchange for some SV-POW!bucks (TM), or just because you have more than them.

Update: answer posted here.

16 Responses to “Little, big”

  1. Biggie is Sauroposeidon and I would guess the smaller one belongs to Giraffatitan(=Brachiosaurus).

  2. Tor Bertin Says:

    Another alternative (albeit slightly less likely) is that they belong to somebody with a really, really long neck.

    Seriously though, I’m absolutely blown away at how huge Sauroposeidon’s cervicals are.

  3. Matt Wedel Says:

    Seriously though, I’m absolutely blown away at how huge Sauroposeidon’s cervicals are.

    Me too! And I’ve had longer to get used to the idea than anyone. But when I stop to think about just how big they are, and what they’re made of–or rather, not made of–I’m still absolutely gobsmacked.

    Which probably has a lot to do with why, more than a decade on, I’m more interested than ever in sauropods, long necks, and pneumaticity. That specimen has cast a LONG shadow over me.

    But enough about big S. Who’s the little friend, do you reckon?

  4. Andrea Cau Says:

    Sauroposeidon and a cervical referred to Malawisaurus?

  5. Tor Bertin Says:

    You are famous on Wikipedia!

  6. Nathan Myers Says:

    I notice that Darren Naish has a comprehensive entry on Wikipedia (that nonetheless fails to note the clear favor in which he is held as the natural successor and heir apparent to David Attenborough), but that Matt’s name, in the Sauroposeidon page, links to what can only called a nascent, inchoate, unrealized article.

  7. Mark Evans Says:

    How about Europasaurus for the little guy?

  8. Zach Miller Says:

    Juvenile Diplodocus?

  9. Cary Woodruff Says:

    The big one is a Sauroposeidon cervical, and the small one may be from Europasaurus or some other smaller Brachiosauridae.

  10. Dave Godfrey Says:

    I’m going to go with Sauroposeidon for the big one, and hazard a guess at Magyarosaurus for the little one.

  11. Michael Ogden Erickson Says:

    The big one is most certainly Sauroposeidon. I’m not sure about the little dude.

  12. Nima Says:

    The big one is surely Sauroposeidon (I know I ‘m beating a dead horse here…)

    The little one looks at first glance to be a brachiosaur, but it’s NOT Giraffatitan. It’s too small for that. If it were Europasaurus, there’s only one cervical it could possibly be (the lower one that was found). It seems a BIT too large for Europasaurus but only a bit. Its crumbly appearance looks like a Wealden sauropod, but those are usually HUGE… I don’t deny the possibility that it could be and upper cervical from Barosaurus or some other diplodocid though the low hanging side arch makes that unlikely given the last time I guessed correctly….

    It doesn’t look like a titanosaur, but I’m a bit murky on those…. It certainly has a “Jurassic” appearance to it.

  13. Mike Taylor Says:

    Nima, It’s definitely not Europasaurus — the preservation is not good enough, and the shape is, well, hard to explain but too blocky. The small vert looks like a drawing of an idealised brachiosaur cervical done by a bright but not particularly observant child, whereas the Europasaurus cervicals are much more elegant and, if you follow me, Ferarri-like.

    And it’s not from the Wealden — I say that not because of the size (it’s about right for most Wealden cervicals, “Angloposeidon” being very much an aberration) but just because I’ve seen ’em all, and this ain’t one of ’em. (If it turns out to be from the Wealden now, I am going to look very stupid :-) )

  14. Lukas Panzarin Says:

    The Large one belong clearly to Sauroposeidon….and the small one belong to a croatian sauropod described in 1998 by Fabio ‘Carniadactylus’ Dalla Vecchia as a possible ‘brachiosaurid’…..and his name is….WN-V1!

  15. Fabio M. Dalla Vecchia Says:

    Lukas is right.

  16. […] the answer to last week’s riddle. The big vertebra was obviously cervical 8 of Sauroposeidon, which you’ve seen here more than […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: