Imposter syndrome revisited
September 13, 2018
My wife Fiona is a musician and composer, and she’s giving a talk at this year’s TetZooCon on “Music for Wildlife Documentaries – A Composer’s Perspective”. (By the way, it looks like some tickets are still available: if you live near or in striking distance of London, you should definitely go! Get your tickets here.)
With less than four weeks to go, she’s starting to get nervous — to feel that she doesn’t know enough about wildlife to talk to the famously knowledgeable and attractive TetZooCon audience. In other words, it’s a classic case of our old friend imposter syndrome.
Wanting to reassure her about how common this is, I posted a Twitter poll:
Question for academics, including grad-students.
(Please RT for better coverage.)Have you ever experienced Imposter Syndrome?
(And feel free to leave comments with more detail.)
Here are the results at the end of the 24-hour voting period:
Based on a sample of nearly 200 academics, just one in 25 claims not have experienced imposter syndrome; nearly two thirds feel it all the time.
The comments are worth reading, too. For example, Konrad Förstner responded:
Constantly. I would not be astonished if at some point a person from the administration knocks at my door and tells me that my work was just occupational therapy to keep me busy but that my healthcare insurance will not pay this any longer.
What does this mean? Only this: you are not alone. Outside of a tiny proportion of people, everyone else you know and work with sometimes feels that way. Most of them always feel that way. And yet, think about the work they do. It’s pretty good, isn’t it? Despite how they feel? From the outside, you can see that they’re not imposters.
Guess what? They can see that you‘re not an imposter, either.
September 13, 2018 at 7:30 pm
The only way to get around ‘Imposter syndrome’ is to speak on a topic that no one but you knows anything about. You are in control. In the case of your wife, she should concentrate on her photography NOT on how well she knows her fauna. That’s how you contribute to an academic audience. ADD something they do not know very well to what they already know well.
September 13, 2018 at 7:32 pm
On her music, not her photography! But otherwise, yes, this is spot on.
December 31, 2018 at 3:02 pm
[…] expanded to take in the Brachiosaurus holotype and Komodo dragons, and Mike blogged about imposter syndrome. The most personally satisfying event in September was that Jessie Atterholt and I started to get […]